Monday, November 12, 2012

SNSD without Taeyeon?


Discussion in 'Korean Music / KPOP' started by GG.BRO JunHyoJul 1, 2012.

I was just wondering about SNSD and taeyeon. ive seen their stage performances in lieu of a few members.i havaent seen a full stage without taeyeon except at Gag concert and Jessica took her lines just fine and still mind blowing. Although Taeyeon is one of the most renowned singers in kpop. some members like tiff, seo and sica sing really well and have powerful voices, i think they could still reach their position without her (taeyeon is still a vital member and people mainly see SNSD's singing talent because of her)but i dont think they would be seen as talented without her. would their songs still sound just fine?could they survive?would they still be at the top?who would take her spot?

i think there may be more lyrics split between 8 so i guess we would see the dancer members sing more and their skill would be tested and continually pressured involved, so i guess we would see SNSD's singing talent as a whole. for example, when tiffany was absent for their stage performance of boyfriend and genie, i didnt know sooyoung could sing really well and i didnt think sunny could belt, but they both did.i think jessica could take her spot. IMO she sings just as well and she usually acompanies taeyeon in belting out notes, but her voices is a little less controlled.

DOES ANYONE HAVE A VIDEO WHERE SNSD HAS A STAGE WITHOUT HER? im only curious how they would do without her since she is a a really powerful and flawless singer.
ky31 and ahutch like this.


?

Would they survive and be still be No.1 Girl group, and who would take her place?

No they would flop without Taeyeon.29 vote(s)22.0%
No, simply no.46 vote(s)34.8%
Yes, Jessica would take main14 vote(s)10.6%
Yes, Tiffany would take main9 vote(s)6.8%
Yes, Seohyun would take main3 vote(s)2.3%
Yes, Sunny would take main0 vote(s)0.0%
they could manage....27 vote(s)20.5%
They could do better without her4 vote(s)3.0%
  1. GG.BRO JunHyoSONE OPPAR

    Member Since:
    Jan 11, 2011
    Message Count:
    1,128
    Likes Received:
    762
    Trophy Points:
    113